Mom to Mom Nutrition

Katie Serbinski, M.S., R.D., is a registered dietitian and millennial mom, blogging about healthy recipes, child and mom nutrition, and motherhood.

Home » Food & Recipes » Dessert » Banana Cream Pie Cups [+ ice cream GIVEAWAY]

Banana Cream Pie Cups [+ ice cream GIVEAWAY]

29 Comments

Banana yogurt and vanilla ice cream make one sweet frozen pie filling in these banana cream pie cups!

Banana yogurt and vanilla ice cream make one sweet frozen pie filling in these banana cream pie cups!

This weekend was HOT. Hot and humid. Heat advisory, bad hair day humid kind of hot folks. So that meant two things: 1. We played outside for no more than an hour with water toys [yes, Mom got drenched] and 2. When we came inside from the heat wave the whole family wanted a treat to cool off with. No plain Jane popsicles for this crew! Mom had some extra time this weekend [remember, we were only outside for an hour] so I treated my guys to these banana cream pie cups. Think pie meets the freezer and becomes one frozen sweet treat!

Banana yogurt and vanilla ice cream make one sweet frozen pie filling in these banana cream pie cups!

Since having kids I find myself creating more bite-sized or kid-sized recipes. And that actually works in my caloric-favor when I make a new dessert. Like I mentioned in my Avocado Ice Pops post, when it comes to ice cream I’m not one for pint portion control. But I can have one or two of these banana cream pie cups and feel good about it! Plus the filling is a mixture of yogurt and ice cream—- see what I did there! [Inspiration for this banana cream pie filling came from my friend Lindsay’s Peanut Butter and Jelly Ice Cream Pie recipe].

Banana yogurt and vanilla ice cream make one sweet frozen pie filling in these banana cream pie cups!

If you are not a banana fan no worries, you can easily swap the flavored yogurt and fruit topping for strawberry, blueberry, lemon, you name it! You can also replace the peanut butter drizzle with chocolate or caramel drizzle. Now once you feast your eyes on this recipe don’t forget to scroll down to learn more about today’s giveaway! Oh and PS. If you give your kids popsicles instead of making these banana cream pie cups I totally understand— no judgment there! But if you have some extra time you won’t want to miss out on making this one!

5.0 from 4 reviews
Banana Cream Pie Cups
 
Print
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
 
Author:
Recipe type: Dessert
Serves: 12 servings
Ingredients
  • 1- 16-ounce refrigerated package of sugar cookie dough
  • 1 cup vanilla ice cream, softened
  • 1 cup banana flavored yogurt
  • 1 medium sized banana, sliced into 12 rounds
  • ½ cup peanut butter, melted
Instructions
  1. Heat oven to 350. Spray muffin pan with cooking spray. Slice cookie dough into 12 equal slices, about ½ inch thick each.
  2. Place 1 cookie dough round in each muffin cup. Using your fingers, press the dough to mold to the shape of the muffin cup. Bake for 15 minutes. Cool completely in the muffin pan until removing.
  3. Meanwhile, combine the yogurt and ice cream in a medium sized mixing bowl. Using a standard size ice cream scoop, fill each sugar cookie muffin cup with a scoop of the yogurt ice cream mixture. Top with a sliced banana.
  4. Place the filled cups on a non-stick cookie sheet. Freeze for at least one hour before serving. Drizzle with melted peanut butter or chocolate chip if desired.
Notes
Cook time includes time spent freezing.

There’s more where these banana cream pie cups came from! I’ve teamed up with my friends at Milk Means More to provide one lucky winner with an AWESOME frozen dairy treat themed giveaway in honor of National Ice Cream Month. The giveaway includes:

PicMonkey Collage

Need I say more to get you to enter?! Use the widget below to enter. Winner must be over theage of 18 and have a US mailing address. Winner will be contacted via email and will have 48 hours to reply before another winner is chosen. Good luck! And stay cool my friends!

Disclaimer: I am proud to partner with the United Dairy Industry of Michigan to bring you healthy recipes made with cow’s milk. Because of these great partnerships I am able to share delicious and nutritious family-friendly recipes. As always all opinion and ideas are 100% my own. Find out why Milk Means More on Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, Pinterest, and Instagram.

Sign Up For Email Updates

slow cooking 101Subscribe to get email updates and my FREE Slow Cooking 101 printable. Use my basic formula to build healthy fix-it and forget-it meals the whole family will love!
I share special behind-the-scenes snapshots from our life, plus Mom to Mom tips, nutritional advice and much more. Plus, be the first to find out about upcoming events, new products and much more.

Comments

  7. This is such a cute idea! :] I love sugar cookies, and these look delicious! <3 I haven't had a banana cream pie in forever, but this would definitely do the trick!

    Reply

  17. I’m pretty smitten with these 🙂 I ‘d love to have one as a sweet treat after each meal! They are adorable and the perfect size!

    Reply

  24. These look delicious! I need to make them for my son. I’ll substitute the peanut butter for fake stuff though because my husband has a severe allergy. I love your food photography, it’s so appealing. And you caramel drizzle is perfection! I always love seeing your new recipe posts. They are inspiring. Keep them coming! Question: Which plugin do you use for your recipe “card”?

    Reply

  28. I LOVE these! I make mini lemon tarts for parties pretty frequently this same way – pressing sugar cookie dough into muffin pans and then filling them. But I never thought to make a frozen treat like this! It’s almost like an ice cream cookie sandwich, but with better portion control. So smart, Katie!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Latest Posts

[hello toddlers!]
[hello toddlers!]